New York, NY – November 1, 2024 Russia Fines Google: In an unprecedented move that sent shockwaves through the tech and financial worlds, a Russian court has fined Google $20 decillion (2 undecillion) over alleged content violations on YouTube near the end of last month. The sum is unimaginable—an amount that surpasses even the global GDP (the size of the global economy), according to international monetary fund figures. As seen above, $20 decillion is a 2 followed by 34 zeros. This decision, reportedly in response to Google’s restrictions on certain Russian media outlets on YouTube channels, marks a critical escalation in the ongoing legal matters between Russia and American tech companies. Moscow-based lawyer Ivan Morozov says there is no cap on the total, according to businessinsider.com.
The fine, which was issued amidst mounting tensions following Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, was described by Russian news agency TASS as a “civil judgment with substantial consequences.” It is widely seen as a reaction to YouTube’s suspension of several pro-Russian channels, including prominent accounts such as RIA FAN, which is closely associated with Russian state media. Google, the parent company of YouTube, had previously faced accusations of censoring Russian content and blocking Russian TV channels due to sanctions and pressure from Western governments.
The case began in 2020 when Google blocked YouTube channels belonging to Yevgeny Prigozhin -the public face of Wagner Group-, and oligarch Konstantin Malofeev, according to NBC News. Both men are strong supporters of Putin, and the Russian invasion of Ukraine. This legal action could have an adverse effect on Google’s commercial operations in Russia. Google is one of the world’s wealthiest companies. Even so, the colossal fine dwarfs the company’s market value and could theoretically bankrupt any entity on Earth. The fine’s symbolism reflects the Russian government’s stance on tech companies accused of interfering with its broadcast activities. Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov publicly supported the judgment, stating that it was necessary to counter the “actions of our broadcasters” and the “unlawful termination of accounts,” which he claims have negatively impacted Russian media outlets.
“Google and YouTube have repeatedly undermined Russian channels by terminating accounts, restricting content, and suspending channels under the guise of sanctions,” said Peskov. He added that such actions against Russian media channels were “an affront to the Russian state and its citizens.”
In May 2021, Russia’s media regulator Roskomnadzor accused Google of restricting YouTube access to Russian media outlets, including RT and Sputnik, and supporting “illegal protest activity” according to BBC news. Beyond YouTube, the case targets Google’s broader commercial ecosystem in Russia. Many Russian authorities have criticized Google’s Russian subsidiary for its handling of Google AdSense accounts, which are essential to the revenue of several Russian broadcasters and media agencies. Allegations include the suspension of monetization for pro-Russian channels and the prohibition of new account creation for state-run media outlets. Russian officials claim these moves represent an orchestrated effort by American tech companies to stymie Russia’s information-sharing abilities.
The scale of the fine has left analysts and industry experts bewildered. Even in dollar terms, the sum—$20 decillion—is unfathomable, exceeding conceivable market value by orders of magnitude. According to a report by the Moscow Times, the fine has no precedent and is likely unenforceable in practical terms, given that it is billions of times larger than Google’s total assets.
Legal experts speculate that the Kremlin intends to leverage the fine as a symbolic threat to Google’s management, adding pressure on the US tech giant to ease restrictions on Russian content. “Such a fine cannot be understood in monetary terms,” commented an analyst. “But it represents a growing willingness by Russian authorities to penalize American tech companies beyond conventional boundaries.”
While Google has not publicly responded to this staggering judgment, the tech giant’s future operations in Russia remain uncertain, with many questioning how long Google’s management will sustain its Russian subsidiary under such intense financial and regulatory scrutiny. With each quarterly earnings report potentially impacted, Google parent Alphabet faces difficult decisions in maintaining any connection to the Russian market.
As this case develops, it underscores the stark divide between Russian authorities and American technology companies, likely influencing the stance of other global entities in the tech sector. Whether or not the Moscow court’s unprecedented fine will ultimately impact Google’s approach to content in Russia remains to be seen, but it undeniably sends a clear message of Moscow’s resolve against what it views as the undue influence of American technology in Russian information channels.
Related:
